I would rank them thus, from favorite to least-favorite:
1. Maple Melodies
Yup, I liked this one best. It had fun You've Got Mail (1998) overtones, it had none of the things that kind of drive me nuts in romance books (such as miscommunication -- it had a deliberate withholding of information, but that is different), and it somehow felt like a faster read than the other three. Maybe because it doesn't flip back and forth between past and present the way the other three did, which was sometimes disorienting and made the books easier to put down and go do something else.
In Maple Melodies, the youngest Remillard sibling, Ginny (who wants to be called Virginia now because she is not a kid anymore, okay?) finally admits to herself that her longtime crush on Ryan, her older sisters' best friend, is more than a crush. And he is spooked by that, for reasons of his own.
There's a lot of discussion of music in this one, as you might expect from the title. And hijinks and shenanigans and a lot of PDA and so on.
Random: I really like that all the book titles involve the middle name of whichever Remillard sibling it's about. That was a nice touch.
If This was a Movie, I Would Rate It: PG-16 for occasional vague and mild innuendo about what various married couples want to do together, lots of attraction between a man and a woman, many instances of dialog between friends being pretty open about their attraction to other people, and several not-extremely-detailed kissing scenes. No smut, but more smoochy content than I would hand to a young teen. No cussing or violence.











